Picture
I am in front of the computer most of the day at work. This means my eyes get very tired. Sometimes when my eyes get tired, I feel the need to take breaks. When I take breaks, I sometimes fumble around and find odd things at my desk just to kind of entertain myself and save my eyes from becoming totally blurry. So I picked up one of these paper clip things. (I know what you’re saying: you took a five minute break and the best thing you could think to do was play with a paperclip?!) What can I say, I’m a true paper pusher!

Back to the paper clips, you might have seen them before. They don’t have the ordinary shape of regular metal paper clips and they are plastic which means they won’t discolor paper when you attach them to paper. The name on the top of the clip says “Plastiklips”. What an exciting (and nuanced name)! Its genius, I mean why didn’t I think of it? Calling a plastic paper clip “Plastiklip”. So fanciful. So catchy. So descriptive.

Then I got to thinking (also while on my break, well maybe on my next break): did somebody get a trademark on this? So being the trademark buff that I am, I made a trip to the USPTO website and ran a search for “Plastiklips” and, sure enough, up pops this trademark registration:


Picture
Picture
Now this just seems odd to me because, well, the trademark is registered for “plastic paper clips”. On the principal trademark register, no less. A trademark , “plastiklips” for “plastic paper clips”. ‘What’s the big deal?’ you might ask. Generally, a trademark cannot describe the goods that it is used on. Marks like “Blackoil” for goods such as synthetic oil that is black in color are not eligible for registration, at least not right off the bat. These kinds of trademarks are only eligible for registration if they have acquired what is called “secondary meaning”, meaning (sorry) that consumers attribute the trademark to a particular source. Descriptive terms which have acquired secondary meaning (and are now considered trademarks) include HOLIDAY INN, AMERICAN GIRL, and ALL BRAN.

But not every trademark can acquire secondary meaning. It’s not one of those things that just happens. Trademark owners sometimes have to invest significantly in marketing and may even have to obtain a consumer survey (which can be hugely expensive). Seem like an unfair burden to place on someone who put their creative juices to coming up with a slick trademark? Imagine the hardships in the marketplace that would ensue if words that described a class of goods was trademarked? Wouldn’t other makers of products who wanted to describe their goods using the same descriptive word run afoul of the trademark owners’ rights? This problem has cropped up time and time again where one company has a descriptive trademark and they try to prevent some other company (usually a competitor in the same field) from using the trademark.

This strategy of enforcing a descriptive mark can get dicey, though, because a competitor that is using the descriptive trademark on their goods could file a petition to cancel the trademark owners’ descriptive mark. And unless the trademark owner has some pretty compelling evidence showing that the trademark has acquired secondary meaning, the trademark could be invalidated for all to use. This is exactly what happened in the case of the battle over the mark FISH FRI where Zatarains’ trademark registration for the FISH FRI trademark was cancelled by another food company which wanted to use “FISH FRY” for food frying stuff. Zatarain’s got fried alright!

Getting back now to my paper clip inquiry, what of the viability of the PLASTIKLIPS trademark? I found this other paper clip company that makes the same type of plastic paper clip, but uses the name “Plastic Clips”. Of course, they haven’t tried to get a trademark for this name (any attorney that took that case would be engaging in gross malpractice), but isn’t “Plastic Clips” pretty much identical to PLASTIKLIPS? Seems nearly identical phonetically and conceptually. If the two trademarks are similar, that seems like a recipe for an infringement suit doesn’t it? Unless you have a descriptive trademark like PLASTIKLIPS and you are holding on to that registration as the last great vestige of hope in your paper clip empire!

Seriously though, I don’t think I would waste the money on a lawsuit against a company that used the phrase “Plastic Clips” for their product, especially if I knew I was going to lose. This all begs the question though: why does the owner of the PLASTIKLIPS mark continue to renew their trademark? Maybe it’s a clip of nostalgia on the part of the owner. Who knows.

Anyways the takeaway is that if you are going to use a descriptive word or phrase as your trademark, make sure that you are ready to expend the significant resources that it takes to prove that your mark has acquired secondary meaning. As they say in sports, go big or go home. 


 


Comments

12/02/2014 3:15am

I like the valuable information you provide in your articles.

Reply

The acquisition of knowledge on the foundation of assignment and essay writing is becoming very popular. The abilities Rae coined and enhanced. The assignment is very popular part of graduation level.

Reply

The assignment is very difficult exercise in the realm of academics. The skills are utilized and effectively used. The production of knowledge is ensured and secured.

Reply

Nicely written post! I must thank you for posting this blog because the topic is very much in demand today and everyone wants to read about it. Thanks

Reply
08/25/2015 11:18pm

You truly have a critical way of thinking. Creativity is evident in you. Researching on this "plastiklips" is very unique in a workplace wherein most of the employees have no time in giving attention to small affairs like this plastic clip. Being able to create connections among diverse ideas can lead to generation of new creative ideas, like what you've done. Thanks for sharing this post.

Reply

This is really great information found here, I really like your blog. Thanks very much for the share. Keep posting.

Reply
12/08/2015 10:35am

We Offer Cheap Essays and They are Written After Thoroughly Understanding Your Precise Requirements. Thus, You Have Nothing to Worry About.

Reply

This problem has cropped up time and time again where one company has a descriptive trademark and they try to prevent some other company.

Reply

As the name proposes, secured abettor bike advances are achievable edge a security. As aegis a borrower can early the bike that he is advancement purchase. Associating with for Aussie bike credits can be as cutting as drawing in for the bicycle.

Reply
01/03/2016 4:28am

Unmistakably, there is best reasonable there are no-obstruction relationship in Australia that change bike credits at disturbing ingestion rates. Interestingly, the examination is in watchful the fitting bank. Unmistakably, not all moneylenders are the same;

Reply
01/07/2016 10:54am

Use our professional essay writing help and you will be pleasantly surprised by the cost and quality of this service.

Reply
01/11/2016 9:53pm

Our website is number 1 in Auditing Assignment Help and Auditing Homework Help. This is preferred destination for various students to get their Audit Projects and Homework Done.

Reply

We are No. 1 in Electronics Engineering Assignment Help; Hire us for your Electronics Engineering Project and Homework Help.

Reply
01/11/2016 10:48pm

Physics Homework Help is available for Physics Projects and Homework and assignments.

Reply
01/11/2016 11:46pm

Core Functionality C# Assignment Help, Online C# Homework & Project Help The core functionality of ASP.NET AJAX is divided into two parts, the AJAX Extensions and the AJAX Ubrary AJAX Extensions.

Reply
01/24/2016 8:00am

. If a analysis allows the being signing it to accomplish an actual acquittal to addition as a aftereffect of advantageous the annual holder for that privilege, it is referred to as a traveler's check. Such a analysis can be replaced in case of annexation or accident and are actual accepted with travelers.

Reply
11/02/2017 4:22am

This is nice post which I was awaiting for such an article and I have gained some useful information.

Reply
11/04/2017 3:14am

The following idea is super, I'm fond of wood working, especially when the little ones are involved! Thank you for the creativeness and positiveness!

Reply
12/07/2017 10:18pm

Beauti Queen amazing kolkata escorts agency alwyas ready for you at your doorstep. Beauti Queen provide you high profile independent girl in kolkata, escorts service in kolkata, kolkata escorts. If you are looking for the ultimate encounter in Kolkata then I am your sophisticated young Kolkata escorts that provides upscale companionship for making your night becomes true.

Reply
12/09/2017 6:01am

Jiya Roy is a high class luxury and premium independent escorts agency in Gurgaon offering sexy independent escort Girls, models and cheap rate call girls for incalls and outcalls and travel arrangements. Female companions available 24/7 for business events, tour guide and much more.

Reply
12/13/2017 7:46am

Renu Das Kolkata Escorts Services has gorgeous females provides Independent Escorts Service in Kolkata call girls at 100% satisfaction with VIP models. Provided Kolkata escorts at our agency are professional in nature and are eager to serve you at your place.

Reply
12/13/2017 10:53pm

Gurgaonfemales.in offers highly educated model from Gurgaon and best Escorts service in Gurgaon through some of its sizzling Independent escorts in Gurgaon Call Girls who are available to customers 24*7.

Reply



Leave a Reply