Picture
Time to put on the I.P. thinking cap!
Sometimes in talking about topical areas, we use generalizations. You know, like when we talk about computers, sometimes we say hard drive, when we are really thinking about RAM. Or we might be talking about our business when we say inventory turnover when we really mean asset turnover. It’s not exactly a Freudian slip, but it is a habit of putting things in umbrella categories.

So I noticed the same thing in intellectual property. In I.P., there are three different “buckets” (well four, if you count trade secret as a category). The buckets are “copyright”, “trademark”, and “patent”. Really innocuous words, right? Way more approachable than asset turnover random access memory (RAM), at least in my opinion. But still, there is all sorts of confusion (no pun intended) about what is what. What is capable of acting as a brand and what is capable of protection as a written work. You might have been subjected to this confusion over which I.P. is which, perhaps because you see the, TM, ®, and © symbols used seemingly interchangeably across different items. Sometimes the confusion can be taken to such extremes that multiple symbols are used simultaneously. Yep, just like what happened here, where the owner of a nut stand went nuts with using the official legal designations attached to the name of his product.

This news story about a Chinese company attempting to obtain a trademark on the word “Snowden” for a type of electric car with “top-secret” technology (which is where the Snowden name will come into play) is a further manifestation of the amalgamation of protections of I.P. under one umbrella. The article talks in one breath about how the company has applied for a “patent” and then in another breath it uses the word “brand”. Could it be a simple journalistic error or is it the result of a deeper confusion (no pun intended) about the true purpose of a trademark? This is not a post about “copyright vs. trademark” in the traditional sense and how to use each type of protection properly because there are already a gazillion of those on the net (and I’m all about originality!), including one from the USPTO itself. Instead, this post is more of a rumination on the tendencies for people to get confused about the purposes of legal protections. Now I’m not trying to be the grammar police here. I just want to understand what is truly going on in people’s minds when they confuse trademark, patent, and copyright.

It all comes down to this (essentially): anything that can designate a source for particular goods or services in the marketplace is a trademark. Anything that is an original, creative work of authorship (with some exceptions, such as actual ideas or useful things like tool designs and/or door handles, completely random, I know) is protected by a copyright. And patents protect useful, non-obvious and new inventions or discoveries including machines, methods of manufacture, or mixtures of things together constituting compositions of matter. Seems like pretty distinct categories, right? You have trademarks that protect symbols that have some kind of value in the marketplace (you use them as logos, connect them to products and services, and market them). Copyrights correspond broadly to works of art, which (on the whole) are completely different from symbols that are used in the marketplace. And patents deal with technical stuff. Simple enough.

But where does all the confusion as to the differences between trademark and copyright come to the fold? One point of confusion might be that symbols (such as the ubiquitous Mickey Mouse ears) may be associated with copyrighted works. So people see the mouse ears (which may not have the © or ®) and a movie instantly comes to mind, which most people easily recognize as a copyrightable work. Another point of confusion might be that logos (classified as pictorial work) are potentially copyrightable works, so people assume that (as a work of art) the logo gets copyright protection. It seems more difficult to trace the source of confusion over the significance of the word patent, but perhaps the confusion stems from the fact that anything that is proprietary is assumed to be exclusive, so someone may automatically think that something which was created by a company can be “theirs”, or otherwise it can be patented.

At the risk of creating even more confusion over the subject, certain objects can be protected by multiple types of I.P. For example, a shoe design can be protected by a design patent and can eventually be protected as trade dress (a type of trademark protection) if the shoe acquires secondary meaning (widespread recognition in the marketplace by a group of consumers). In fact, this is exactly what Disney is doing with its Mickey Mouse character: because the copyright on the original Steamboat Willy film is close to ending, Disney is now running a prominent portion of the clip before feature films in an attempt to turn the clip into a trademark. So now instead of being a creative work, the film clip has bridged the gap to become a useful symbol in the marketplace that can tip consumers off as to where the film that succeeds it came from.

At the end of the day, just remember this simple framework:

1.       Trademarks are for things (words, designs, product packaging, sounds, even film clips) that can identify the source of where your product came from.
2.       Copyrights are for written, designed, or theatrical works that were created by an author and are not intended to exclusively identify a source, at least in a commercially significant way.
3.       Patents are for inventions or discoveries (not abstract ideas), but the kinds of things that require technical drawings, flowcharts, schematics, and prototypes to describe.

 


Comments

06/18/2015 10:25pm

Education teaches us to value one single and small thing in our life. As we can never ever judge the value of single small thing in our life. So we have to value everything as we never know what will become the source for our identity.

Reply
10/20/2016 12:53am

showbox apk download for android devices. Free download from showbox official webisite. Free movie streaming service

Reply
09/14/2015 4:48am

Yes with copyright, patent and trademark a property is not meant to be own as per the regulations. It's highly influential in any sort of conditions. That was a guidance provided above about them.

Reply
11/15/2016 12:30am

Get all information related to aadhar card on Eaadharcardstatus.in like , online status, list of documents for identity and many more information here.

Reply
11/01/2015 5:36pm

So not all the bananas are same. Brilliant exposition! I appreciate how clearly you were able to differentiate the three. I am very particular about word meanings too and am not happy about their getting interchanged too. The shift+f7 button's been widely abused and differences between words and their meanings are very much neglected. Some interchanges are forgivable but for the three mentioned in your article, one should be very careful, especially that it is our businesses or our products or our works that are at stake. Ignorance about their differences may prove costly or may have a dire result in the end. It's always better to be well-informed.

Reply
11/30/2016 5:08am

Latest movies is always a desire of everyone many people need an app which gives a start to end movie download solution due to present scenario showbox is an app which fulfill all need regarding movie download and gives high definition movies anytime.

Reply
01/03/2016 4:26am

In any case, you don't see no-detainment money for that. So what else? Do whatever it takes not to gather your fantasy on hold. You can yearly an abettor bike up to this chance to picking up your assent bicycle. Moreover, on the off impromptu that you are uniting with for a joined arrangement, demand on secured abettor bike credits, with which you can aback a bike central of you're sparing cash framework.

Reply
10/25/2016 1:33am

Getting trouble in movie download then you need an app like showbox where you will get best ever latest movies collection and you just get whatever you want and the best part is it's easy in use and you will always get high definition movies.

Reply
02/09/2016 1:59pm

good job

Reply
06/15/2016 6:20am

Wow, this article is pleasant, my younger sister is analyzing these kinds of things, so I am going to tell her.

Reply
12/14/2016 11:44pm

A plagiarism detector is a software application designed to make certain that a written work being published on the internet is original and has not been copied from another written article already available on the internet. Although a plagiarism detector is not always necessary there are times when this is the only way to determine without a doubt if something will be accepted as your own work on the internet.

Reply

Useful information… I am very happy to read this.. thanks for giving us this useful information. Fantastic walk-through.

Reply

You have a great sense of writing I must say. Your post has those facts which are not accessible from anywhere else. It’s my humble request to u please keep writing such remarkable articles.

Reply

emotional, hormonal, arterial or even muscle.

Reply
03/12/2017 11:51am

Zenerx is secure, trustworthy, simple to buy, and also includes a 90-day absolutely no concerns requested money-back ensure.

Reply
03/13/2017 6:03am

Investigation indicates it may safeguard the experience associated with defense cellular material which experience chemical substances that could or else hinder their own regular functionality.

Reply
03/13/2017 5:32pm

Occasionally some thing over-the-counter although isn't very sufficient for any lady to obtain back again the actual sexual interest he or she as soon as suffered from.

Reply
03/14/2017 10:07am

The truth is that it must be section of the Christian's training course.

Reply
03/30/2017 11:28am

The sense the general that as well as other parts of a body at continuous trainings the member becomes more tightened strong and blood circulation considerably increases, so and erection force.

Reply
05/02/2017 10:35am

thank you

Reply
05/02/2017 10:49am

great blog

Reply
05/02/2017 10:55am

great job

Reply
05/02/2017 11:01am

nice blog

Reply
05/02/2017 11:07am

thanks you great blog

Reply
05/02/2017 11:27am

thanks for the given best info

Reply
05/02/2017 11:36am

thanks for the given great information

Reply
05/29/2017 12:11am

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained!

Reply
06/06/2017 11:24pm

Remembering these favorable circumstances, one can simply select online payday trade propel credit when out need of earnest money at crisis circumstances.

Reply
06/11/2017 1:22am

Credit card loan. Diverse Visa organizations apply distinctive APRs.

Reply
06/11/2017 10:02am

Of course, you'll miss them and they'll miss you, yet summer camp is an extraordinary open door for your kids to figure out how to meet new individuals, cooperate as a group and how to finish undertakings.

Reply
06/11/2017 1:08pm

To make up for loses that he without a doubt brings about subsequently of this practice, the moneylender needs to charge considerably higher rates of enthusiasm for request to make his business gainful.

Reply
06/25/2017 1:36am

A VPN app can be a seriously powerful tool for defending your online freedom. If you want the best VPN Service for Android - make sure to read our comparison of the best Android VPN Providers first before you pay too muchAcquiring access to websites and content blocked in your country, encrypting your traffic to protect it from prying eyes, and watching Netflix from anywhere in the world – these are the most basic things any VPN app can do for you. For over 10 years, Psiphon has helped internet users around the world to defeat censorship.

Reply
07/13/2017 2:54am

the trademark pronouncation isn't too important at all, the most important is the value for its brand. For example there is an entrepreneur in roof business using new technology for increase his product and trademark for his value product.

Reply
07/18/2017 3:18am

As what you said Trademarks are for things designs and product, I have a roofing business and I prefer to looking at the material using, quality design, and product offered. Its how I put trademark for my brand and product.

Reply

I just love my life. And I really Enjoy my work. Why don't you join me?

Reply

What a fantastic publish! Other than the seriously helpful ideas, it really is just really ! Thanks a great deal in your strategies!!

Reply



Leave a Reply