Picture
Burger King: King of Fries. Is that some variety of anagram?
In case you hadn’t heard, Burger King is attempting to assert its authority as the King of fast food. Not that the fast food wars are anything new, but it seems that Burger King’s latest public relations campaign is frying a lot of people’s brains and testing the bounds of the most seasoned fast food ad campaigns.

This week, Burger King made a series of announcements across Twitter and other social media outlets that it was temporarily re-branding itself as “Fries King”. This prompted some business journalists to lament the fact that Burger King’s ad stunt is really just a gimmicky ad campaign that is only contributing to confusion on the part of consumers. No, not the same type of confusion that we trademark lawyers speak of whenever a trademark owner finds that a third-party is using a logo that is similar in appearance to the trademark owners’ logo. Burger King’s temporary re-branding couldn’t be confusing in that sense because consumers are keenly aware that “Burger King” and “Fries King” probably one and the same. After all, the Fries King logo uses the same coloring and arrangement of elements as the Burger King logo not to mention that the main point of contact between consumers and the Fries King logo is at a physical storefront for Burger King, where consumers undoubtedly recognize other symbols associated with Burger King.


Picture

Most complaints I have seen seem to pertain to the fact that Burger King is somehow getting away from its mission, its core specialty. And that, of course, is serving burgers!Could Burger King be driving at some other, more long-term goal of making its “King” mark into a family mark, akin to what McDonalds has done with its Chicken McNuggets and McCafe products?

A trademark becomes a family mark if multiple marks share a prefix, suffix, word, syllable, or other feature. A commonly-shared component of multiple marks can become a family trademark if the trademark owner advertises the family in such a way that the public recognizes the shared element as identifying products or services originating from the trademark family owner. Gaining protection for a single element of a mark isn’t so easy as simply coming up with multiple marks with common elements. Courts have held that the existence of a family mark is a question of fact and is based on the uniqueness of the common elements of the different marks and other factors including how widely the family mark element was used in advertising, promotion, and its inclusion in a number of registered and unregistered marks owned by the trademark owner.

In the case where the “Mc” prefix was found to be a prefix, a competing food restaurant aimed to brand itself “McBagels” and serve (surprise surprise) bagels and other breakfast items. The court found that McDonald’s was able to develop tons of recognition for its “Mc” mark by using it extensively on pizza (McPizza), chicken, and its famous breakfast sandwich, “Egg McMuffin” (side note: even my spell check recognizes that “McMuffin” and McNugget” are properly spelled words!). Moreover, the media had seized on this strategy by McDonalds and referenced events held in connection with McDonalds or anything even referencing McDonalds with the same “Mc” prefix. For example, the court referenced a nationally-syndicated political cartoon depicting President Ronald Reagan in front of a “McRonald’s” sign in connection with golden arches.

In the case where the “Mc” prefix was found to be a prefix, a competing food restaurant aimed to brand itself “McBagels” and serve (surprise surprise) bagels and other breakfast items. The court found that McDonald’s was able to develop tons of recognition for its “Mc” mark by using it extensively on pizza (McPizza), chicken, and its famous breakfast sandwich, “Egg McMuffin” (side note: even my spell check recognizes that “McMuffin” and McNugget” are properly spelled words!). Moreover, the media had seized on this strategy by McDonalds and referenced events held in connection with McDonalds or anything even referencing McDonalds with the same “Mc” prefix. For example, the court referenced a nationally-syndicated political cartoon depicting President Ronald Reagan in front of a “McRonald’s” sign in connection with golden arches.

Having a particular component designated as a family mark is huge because it allows the owner of the family mark to prevent any competitor from using a similar element in their name, even if the trademark owner does not sell the same products as the competitor and does not use the same exact trademark as the competitor is using. This is why McDonald’s was able to prevent the McBagels trademark from being used. One concern with recognizing that a certain component of a trademark actually qualifies for protection is that it grants trademark owners a virtual monopoly on that particular component, something some trademark attorney’s deem a right in gross. As a general policy matter, it is not cool to grant a particular trademark owner a right in gross (at least in the circumstance of a family mark) because it gives that trademark owner rights to any and all trademarks that include a particular element, even if the trademark owner hasn’t developed goodwill for a particular reiteration of a family trademark. On the other hand, the attempt by a trademark owner to acquire a family trademark is wholly consistent with a trademark owner’s interest in maximizing brand protection because a family mark maximizes brand equity and contributes to the overall mark becoming famous.

Picture
Tomato king. To make the ketchup that goes with the fries from Fries King!
So could Burger King succeed in obtaining the same kind of protection for the “King” component? Perhaps. It would first have to establish that the “KING” suffix is used across a number of different products, but used in such a way that a consumer could draw associations between the different products offered at Burger King. One of the ways that Burger King could accomplish this is through the branding of different food items like fries with “King” or milkshakes “Shake King”. You get the idea. There is one problem with this approach: there are already many other “kings” in the fast food industry. A simple search of the U.S. trademarks database uncovered “Smoothy King”, “Donut King”, “Wing King”, and “Sandwich King”. This isn’t necessarily a deal breaker for Burger King. After all, with the amount of pull Burger King and the BK brand have overall, it isn’t unreasonable to think that the “King” component, when used properly by Burger King, could capture the coveted status of family mark.

But it won’t be easy. Burger King, like McDonald’s and Toys-R-Us, will have to use the “KING” suffix consistently across multiple products. Consistent means for many years and across many different marketing mediums. And because of the way family marks works, getting family mark status for “King” would make Burger King the “King” of “King”, so to speak, at least for fast food in America. This would be good for Burger King because it could claim a lot more goodwill by virtue of its “King” suffix being potentially attributable to more items, even without investing serious money to develop these alternative outlets. 

 


Comments

03/26/2015 3:17am

Surprise Circle is fast growing eCommerce site, popular with its quality women apparel, clothing, lingerie, jewelry, free surprises gifts on every purchase

Reply
07/05/2015 3:08pm

The interest towards the study may also influenced by the help of extra-curricular activities in the schools. These activities help the students to build up confidence and different programs are also help in the character development.

Reply
09/22/2015 12:37am

Very most article...

Reply

Burger king is very famous name in the fast food world and they are producing many foods for people like burgers and fries etc. Here in blog there are discussed about their further facilities which are amazing and very attractive for people to visit them and enjoy. For complete details one have to read the whole blog carefully.

Reply

Don't like this kind of food.

Reply
01/17/2016 8:05am

One affair that I did was to change into a bit for payday beforehand affiliations with the ambition that I could get paid from apparent bodies accepting payday credits. A brace of bodies are about activity to get them so there is no afflatus active why you shouldn't get paid from the adjustment that fabricated you pay to such a degree.

Reply

Very,very, good i hope you enjoy always,thank,s.

Reply
04/07/2016 12:13pm

You're anterior footfall care to be to appreciate the best amount of payday acclaim on offer. Whichever payday acclaim amalgamation you ability aces you should handle what will be the acclimatized absolute that you will owe in the deathwatch of finishing your payday advance.

Reply

With an auto appellation change, banks contemplate the annual of your vehicle, to aces how abounding the alive is able to get. Afore you address a credit, in any case, it challenge to achieve your appointment and framework the admeasurement of auto amore you acquire and how abounding your auto is worth.

Reply
04/27/2016 12:20am

it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.

Reply

Great Post!

Reply
05/25/2016 4:06am

I am actually happy to read your blog post. I discovered a bunches of approaches after seeing your blogs. Great work.

Reply
07/02/2016 11:44am

Keep posting. I have to say i really like your site post.

Reply

Your blog have nice information,

Reply
10/02/2016 10:44am

Wow! This is so funny video and everyone must try to watch it all over. The Rabbi eats a bacon cheese burger in his favorite restaurants. This is lovely news to hear.

Reply
11/20/2016 8:43pm

They are taking a stab at everything to take care of such profound issues that are constantly burrowing holes. They are altering keeping in mind the end goal to settle social and financial issues.

Reply
12/05/2016 5:29am

Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i've been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share.

Reply
01/24/2017 4:35pm

BK fries are pretty good.

Reply

Yeah bk fries are the best.

Reply
05/21/2017 3:49pm

I can't get the main idea, but it's really helpful for additional information.

Reply
06/20/2017 5:29pm

When I saw this web, it's really different than the other. Great Job!

Reply
07/10/2017 12:54am

Very informative post ! There is a lot of information here that can help any business get started with a successful social networking campaign !

Reply
07/24/2017 12:47am

Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that.

Reply
07/30/2017 1:09pm

Wonderful post! We are linking to this particularly great content on our website. Keep up the great writing.

Reply

in1989 is a worldwide pioneer in counselling, innovation, and outsourcing .Built up in 2013 IT administrations organization with more than 50 Workers.Making your organization exceed expectations with an incomprehensible low consumption..

Reply
09/04/2017 4:49am

If we share information to the public, nothing wrong when a Science should be shared to be useful.

Reply
09/07/2017 5:38pm

This place has an unspoiled natural condition, fresh air, shady green trees and a crystal clear beach.

Reply
09/12/2017 9:29pm

Here, You will get our profesional hosting and SEO in a good quality.

Reply
09/20/2017 5:54pm

I am interested in your information. I will wait for your update anytime.

Reply
09/27/2017 9:06am

The bird's native habitat, called Magpie Robin / Oriental Magpie Robin / Straits Robin, is an open forest area, a garden near a residential area. This bird prefers an open area on the edge of the forest compared with in a dense forest. Despite the likes of open areas, there has never been any mention that they also live in areas near the sea / beach.

Reply

How often do they meet with their clients? It is important to know how often your financial advisor expects to meet with you.

Reply
10/12/2017 1:03pm

And now I talk about lovers, and the experience of a young girl in a big city. She wants to become a conformist, and she realises that the only way to do this is to surrender, let go of all her inhibitions. And yet she doesn't want to be seen as a cheap thrill. What does she want? What is her heart's secret desire?

Reply
10/20/2017 8:37pm

Talking about pulau seribu. Thousand Islands archipelago has a small potential for the development of various industries, including mining, fisheries and most importantly tourism.

Reply



Leave a Reply