Picture
I will admit that I have never gotten on the whole Pinterest trip, despite being surrounded by family and friends who love the site. Not that I have anything against the platform; I just don’t understand how it works and have never put the time in to learning. I have so many other social media platforms to keep up with! The basics make enough sense to me that I can summarize them as follows: Pinterest is a type of software platform that allows users to share content in the form of visual bookmarks that others with like interests can browse in order to become more informed about (or be entertained by) a particular subject. Users of the site place items on their digital posting boards. The posting medium is given the name “pin”, a cute reference to the fact that items are digitally pinned to a particular page.

I may not use the site, but one thing about the site (or is it an application? platform?) that did capture my interest was Pinterest’s recent move to protect the “Pin” trademark. Apparently it’s something that the website wants to be known for. Pinterests’ platform is sleek and the concept is cool. It is the perfect play to a consuming audience that thrives on information and the ability to share it. So maybe it was only a matter of time until other market entrants attempted to get a piece of the pie.

Enter Pintrips in 2011 with a similar concept to that of Pinterest: through a website, users can collect, compare, and share information about a particular interest by using a “pin”. Yes, that’s right. Pretty much exactly what Pinterest allows. Pinterest even had their own “pin” button.

What a bunch of pinheads, you might be saying. Didn’t Pintrips know enough not to use a trademark of a well-known company, especially when Pintrips had already pretty much ripped off the rest of Pinterest’s business model? Well maybe, maybe not. I see from the Patent and Trademark Office’s website that Pinterest did file for the “Pin” trademark, but not until August 2012, a full year after Pintrips starting using the “pin” mark on its site. If Pinterest did not file the trademark until after Pintrips started using it, how can Pinterest fairly accuse Pintrips of trademark infringement?

Common law trademark rights, that’s how. You see, although Pinterest hadn’t filed for trademark registration for “pin” until 2012, it had already been using “Pinterest” (and many other words involving “Pin-“) for a few years (2010, at least). Presumably, this is enough time for Pinterest and its PIN trademark to acquire the kind of distinctiveness necessary to be considered a trademark, even if it was descriptive of the underlying service (software that allows users to create and share content by “placing” the items on a page). In other words, Pinterests’ PIN trademark tells users about what the underlying service IS, so it is a descriptive trademark. To acquire trademark rights, Pinterest would have to demonstrate that the consuming public primarily associates PIN with Pinterest, instead of the underlying product (this is why HOLIDAY INN is a trademark, even though the words “Holiday Inn” are descriptive of hospitality services). I have no doubt they would invest as much money as they could to get the best and the brightest experts to prepare a survey to find such distinctivenss.

Once it clears the descriptiveness hurdle, however, Pinterest still has to show actual use of the PIN mark in commerce. Some have the opinion that PIN isn’t really being used as a trademark (that is, the mark is not being used to indicate the source of the mark but is instead used to describe a feature or function, the action of pinning, in this case). This same commentator points to Pinterests’ own use of PIN as a noun (“Your home feed is a collection of pins..”) and a verb (“Join our community and start pinning today!”) as additional evidence that PIN is not a source identifier and is really being used in a generic sense. Indeed, the PIN trademark is used across buttons and other features of Pinterests’ website.

Could Pinterest be a pioneer of a new type of trademark use, one that relies on an affiliation between a specific platform and a function of that particular platform, where a user recognizes a particular word or insignia as having significance? It seems that when a company uses certain trademarks on services offered through a website or software platform, they could be using the mark in a way that does not strictly

Case in point: Facebook’s LIKE button. To like something means “to enjoy” or “to regard in a favorable way”. This seems to be the exact function that the LIKE trademark serves. It allows Facebook users to show their approval or interest in something. Yet, Facebook’s LIKE button has not been challenged as a trademark, yet.
Will Pintrips be able to win the day on its genericness argument? We’ll just have to wait and see. An initial attempt by Pintrips to dismiss Pinterests’ suit on procedural grounds for failure to state a claim failed. Essentially, Pintrips argued that the word PIN is generic and Pintrips could not be liable for infringing on a trademark that is not even a protectable mark. To support their argument that PIN is generic, Pintrips asked the court to accept printouts from webpages where others were using the word “pin” as evidence that PIN is generic. The court said no, mainly because the nature of the “pin” mark itself is disputed, all the more reason to allow the suit to go forward.

This episode indicates the difficulties that new companies (i.e. Pintrips) face in trying to do battle with existing market strongholds, especially if the entrant seeks to use marks or symbols that the market leader regards as a significant source of goodwill. Often times, if the new entrant wants to achieve some kind of result (i.e. replicating a particular user experience that relies partially on some type of I.P.), the entrant should see suits as a type of expected cost and work them into the business model.

That or the entrant just has to create some new niche itself. Which sounds easier to you?

 


Comments

12/19/2014 12:42am

Really like Difficulty Option Baba ji offers 1 simply call address your difficulties by appreciate astrology. We delivers appreciate problem option solutions, really like spells, adore astrology with quickly helpful final result.

Reply
01/02/2015 4:18am

I read your article to learn a lot and hope to see your next article.

Reply
02/01/2015 11:50pm

Its Great Social site. I like that type sites.

Reply
04/22/2015 5:16am

Online shopping across various categories products with Buying Regroupment . you get many offers on many products, and Deal of the day etc.

Reply
04/24/2015 3:46am

I similar to the handy facts you deliver in the content articles. I’ll bookmark your website and look at routinely for many nice content. I am pretty selected I’ll discover numerous new things suitable right here! Better of luck to the future!

Reply
05/05/2015 3:30am

Buy Facebook Likes and boost your online presence today! We match any competitor's price! Also get 100% Money Back Guarantee

Reply
05/13/2015 12:45am

If you visit the blo, here I have set you as the creator of the blog is a creative, I'm very happyg

Reply
06/03/2015 10:36pm

MyBrushes Paint for Mac app is the best Mac paint software to paint on Mac infinite canvas and PLAYBACK drawing Paintbrush for Mac.It's good as ms Paint for Mac.

Reply
06/03/2015 11:13pm

Total Video Converter helps you convert avi to mp4 with fast speed and high quality.

Reply
06/22/2015 1:04am

Thanks for an informative article! I think Pintrips will not win this using the "PIN is a generic term" argument. I know of two companies in the beverage manufacturing industry, who underwent the same thing. The company being accused used the same line of argument that Pintrips did and did not win. The association of the 'generic term' to the other accusing company is just so strong that it's served as its unofficial trademark for quite a while already.

Personally, as a user of Pinterest, I don't think I will take Pintrips seriously. I will just always see it as a replica. Unless, it changes its name.

Reply

This social media is jerking me out. Like all the world go mad bout this stuff. Cant get why?

Reply

Your site always offer some really interesting information. Thank you
for sharing it with us.

Reply
09/08/2015 3:31am

This blog is showing the worth of Pinterest. I have gained many precious tips of social media marketing.

Reply
09/23/2015 1:41am


Always uplifting and beneficial in achieving something

Reply
09/26/2015 5:21am

its really great information i m glad you to found this kind of website..

Reply
09/30/2015 1:30am

The information you provide very interesting and very latest from other websites, we are awaiting further information which might be more interesting, see also here we provide information about health http://goo.gl/bKEQJZ http://goo.gl/6GNwCL http://goo.gl/9ZRpdH http://goo.gl/3aBkiK

Reply

Nice Post. It’s really a very good article. I noticed all your important points. Thanks 

Reply
10/16/2015 7:58am

Does anyone use pinterest in 2015?

Reply

This in itself means nothing as the site you pick could have 3 individuals perusing your data following 12 months. Picking the right report distributer is one of the fundamental keys.

Reply
11/03/2015 12:13pm

Pinterest is an awesome app! I like it very much.

Reply
11/07/2015 3:50am

Here you will discover a Hosting and Domain in the cost of website $1 web hosting with cost-free Domain.
Webtechcoupons

Reply
11/11/2015 10:50am

goood

Reply
11/11/2015 11:56am

In major areas students have more attraction toward education, but unluckily in few areas this attraction rate is low and the reason is poverty which diverts students' attention from education. this is a big challenge for the Government.

Reply

Hide My Ass is the best site for Hide Menu Pricing, Equipment, internet connection secure, IP slot proxies and free proxy list database. Encrypt your internet connection with HMA your privacy. Here is normally huge collection of hide my ass coupons, gives, deals and discount rates December 2015.

Reply
12/13/2015 4:39am

Pinterest is driving more referral traffic than LinkedIn, Google+ and YouTube combined. So, if you as a business owner, have limited time in social media, Pinterest is the best return for your social media time because it equals more traffic to your website. Get more tips by visiting http://thetalentcollectiveagency.com/ website.

Reply
12/15/2015 11:01am

There are so many electronic things which are used in different organization for different purposes. Some of them are very useful in our daily life and some are used off and on.

Reply
01/10/2016 12:58pm

this problem of facebook has been detected as true that you can get fb account online.

Reply
01/11/2016 4:39am

great post thanks.

Reply
01/11/2016 4:40am

such a awesome post thanks.

Reply
01/19/2016 4:24am

While marketing can be tricky, it is the content that makes the site important. If you provide informative content that serves the needs of your visitors, word will spread.

Reply
01/23/2016 7:41pm

Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts. http://penghilangtato.net/penghilang-tato-semarang/ Good jobs…!!!

Reply
http://www.gforceacceleration.com/1/post/2014/03/whereisthemoney-in-social-media.html
01/25/2016 7:13am

http://www.gforceacceleration.com/1/post/2014/03/whereisthemoney-in-social-media.html

Reply
01/29/2016 4:35am

Good post and fantastic blog, Thanks for sharing.

Reply
02/04/2016 1:58am

yeah I like reviewing your write-ups, because the details is intriguing.

Reply
02/12/2016 2:15am

Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing...

Reply
02/15/2016 10:57pm

his is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the excellent work.

Reply
02/16/2016 1:51am

So luck to come across your excellent blog. Your blog brings me a great deal of fun.. Good luck with the site.

Reply
03/04/2016 3:28am

This blog post aids by offering useful details. I would certainly recommend others to look at the post and obtain your expertise boosted-up.

Reply
03/10/2016 2:31am

My friend mentioned to me your blog, so I thought I’d read it for myself. Very interesting insights, will be back for more!

Reply

Incredible points. Sound arguments. Keep up the great work.Thanks for sharing in detail. Your blog is an inspiration! Apart of really useful tips, it's just really!

Reply
11/08/2017 4:10am

Reply
11/17/2017 11:20pm

Delhi-Divas amazing Delhi escorts who is always ready for you at your doorstep. Hurry up to avail the most seductive independent escorts in Delhi. Delhi-Divas escorts agency is providing you with High Quality and Verified girl in Delhi, escorts service in delhi, delhi escorts.

Reply
11/19/2017 1:14am

Beauti Queen provides you a high quality Escort Girl in Delhi, Delhi Escorts, Escorts Service in Delhi offering for dinner dates & your personal entertainment 24x7.

Reply
11/19/2017 1:15am

Beauti Queen provides you a high.

Reply

Reply



Leave a Reply