So…. I decided to elaborate a little more on the previous post on store designs after a weekend spent at the mall with my significant other (yes I found myself, again, in Victoria Secret where many a man has met supreme disappointment when he attempts to pass the time or even find a place to sit). Actually, I was planning on writing another post on store design because the topic is just that complex.

In the previous post I talked a lot about how a store design could be protectable. I even discussed some of the hurdles that a company could face in its bid to obtain protection for store designs. The main hurdle is the difficulty of demonstrating that store design is inherently distinctive or that it has acquired secondary meaning. And the difficulty inherent in demonstrating inherent distinctive is that store designs aren't generally that unique or different from store-to-store. Most store layouts and designs incorporate many "essential" elements like shelving, lighting arrangements, tables, walls and glass. Where a store presents a design and layout that can be specifically defined and linked to a particular source because it has a different arrangement or distinctive, it can acquire distinctiveness over time. Distinctiveness is acquired through continuous use of the same design, active promotion of the design, widespread consumer recognition of the design as associated with a particular source.

But secondary meaning is hard to prove and usually requires providing some pretty compelling evidence (consumer surveys, extensive media attention, significant foot traffic). Another difficulty that even Apple faced: proving that variations in a store's design across different locales did not modify the character of the mark. Almost by necessity, Apple store designs vary by location. This is perfectly understandable, especially when you consider the multitude of factors influencing the design and layout of a store front. Consider the two images below (both images courtesy of apple.com)

Picture
Apple Store in Natick, MA
Picture
Apple Store in Delaware.
Picture
Apple Store in San Francisco, CA.
From these two different designs, the only commonality appears to be the Apple logo prominently featured above the entrance to the store. Neither of the stores really fit within the description that Apple provided in its trademark application, namely a clear glass store front surrounded by rectangular horizontal panels and two narrower panels stacked one either side of the storefront. To be sure, there are stores that fit this profile (like the store in the first picture, above).

Then there are other stores that appear to only incorporate one or two elements described in the application:
Picture
Apple Store at Stanford; Palo Alto, CA.
As you can see, the Stanford store doesn’t appear to incorporate any of the rectangular panels mentioned in the trademark application. It does include the glass façade, recessed rear wall panels with advertising and display tables placed down the middle of the store and along the rear wall.

In response to these variations, the trademark examining attorney asked Apple to specifically identify which stores contained the horizontal panel trade dress and tie its consumer surveys recognizing the distinctiveness of the claimed design to these particular stores. Apple balked (properly, in my opinion) and argued that the differences between its stores were slight and that minor amendments to trade dress have been allowed in the past without new consumer recognition evidence for the amended redesign.

I think I understand where Apple is coming from on this. Their argument appears to be that, while there is a little variation in the designs of its stores, the stores, in essence, make the same impression on a consumer. The problem with this argument is that it blurs the line between specific definitions of the mark and claiming a right for a general “look and feel” scope of rights. While there are certainly similarities between the different Apple store designs, there are some striking differences. The question then becomes are the similarities the kind of items that are protectable as trade dress, or are they merely functional constraints?

Certainly, there are a finite number of ways to present computers and other electronics in a store. Begin with the fact that most consumers want to see a computer, touch it, and play around on it before committing to a purchase (especially when the price tag exceeds $1,000). That requires some sort of display. Because it is a public health hazard to have wires, computers, and people lying around on the floor, simply placing the computers on the ground for people to pick up and use is out. So there has to be some kind of elevated display. The most common type of elevated display (at least for computers) appears to be tables. Also, there has to be some kind of shelving along the walls, to maximize space in the store and manage traffic flow. When you look at the designs for two different stores (Microsoft and Samsung), you can easily pick out common elements. 

Picture
Microsoft Store (image credit: http://www.theverge.com/2011/11/24/2585015/microsoft-store-black-friday-2011-deals)
Picture
Samsung Store in Australia. (Image courtesy of Sydney Morning Herald).
These may be similarities (tables arranged along the length of the store, cantilevered shelving along the walls, and a longer table, almost like a counter, in the rear of the store), but if the elements are not part of what constitutes the mark, then Apple could not claim those elements and, consequently, could not stop other stores from incorporating those elements. But here, Apple described particular table arrangements and design of cantilevered shelving. Most Apple stores (if not all of them) have these elements, so there isn’t a great degree of variation and that portion of the mark really is consistent across different stores.

But what about the other features that are described in Apple’s trademark registration with such a high degree of particularity? The glass façade, the arrangement of rectangular panels around the façade, and the vertical panels at either end of the façade? These definitely do not appear in all Apple store designs. Maybe that doesn’t matter as much, especially if all of the other elements in Apple’s registration appear in the store. After all, if you are 8/10 in terms of included features, have you satisfied a majority of the features? And what if those features leave the same kind of impression with a consumer such that a consumer is able to connect a particular design with Apple as the source? If the latter is true, then slight variations don’t much matter because the essence of the mark is still used in commerce.

Could all stores get away with this kind of variation? Maybe, maybe not. Apple has certainly built a cult following, and their stores are located in some of the higher-traffic shopping centers and locales across the U.S. This kind of “buzz” could be what accounts for the great public awareness regarding the appearance of the Apple store, even if the designs vary across different installments. A famous brand like Apple could therefore manage pretty easily to walk the fine line between trademark design variations and complete mutilation (fancy phrase meaning significant changes to a mark that allows it to lose its commercial significance) than, say, a mom-and-pop with just a few stores in different states.

So the take-away here? The appearance of a trademark in the marketplace (and whether the mark substantially matches the mark as described in a trademark registration) have a direct bearing on whether the trademark will be considered valid. If a mark varies too much from the way it is described in the registration, trademark rights could be forfeited because consumers have a hard time matching a specific design to a particular source.

 


Comments

11/24/2014 6:29am

Really you have done a good job which can help all the visitor at all. I am so benefited to get this news at all. I am so pleased and want to say that you must post more info in the next. Thanks and keep it up...

Reply
11/24/2016 9:34pm

Ultimate Testo Explosion But whilst those can also vary from weight reduction to constructing strength, there’s no denying that Ultimate Testo Explosion a flat belly stays the stamp of.
http://www.strongtesterone.com/ultimate-testo-explosion/

Reply
04/16/2015 10:33pm

Some of children we can also see in our daily life who are habitual to be fulfilled their all requirements otherwise they become angry all the time for not fulfilling their requirements but the thing is we are actually doing wrong with such child.

Reply
05/05/2015 1:50am

Met belasting Amsterdam worden vaak de gemeentelijke belastingen van de stad Amsterdam bedoelt. Deze belasting Amsterdam wordt ook geheven voor ZZPers.

Reply
06/28/2015 7:34am

I can't believe you've made a very good article today. Thank ya...

Reply
07/26/2015 9:13am

thank you so much mas bro.

Reply
08/05/2015 10:40pm

best of the best website in the world.

Reply
08/12/2015 4:54am

Large website is good.

Reply
08/17/2015 9:35pm

someone like you. asyik ya

Reply
08/17/2015 10:47pm

wonderfull place and thanks for this information

Reply
08/18/2015 1:22am

best of the best news in the world

Reply
08/19/2015 12:40am

Gue mah gitu orangnya.

Reply
08/21/2015 11:14pm

like this ok deh thank you

Reply
08/22/2015 12:00am

The teachers are paid to paper checking in formal educational sectors. The teacher check the papers with deep concentration because of reward in the form of amount. The accurate results on time are given to students.

Reply
08/22/2015 1:29am

Move on and work smart. Don't work hard

Reply
09/07/2015 3:06am

Teachers should have always positive attitude towards their students. They should give new opportunity of learning to their students. They should give them creative task to do in class through which their learning process can be meaningful.

Reply
09/25/2015 6:03am

I really like this webpage a great deal, so superior to help keep on posting! Thanks.

Reply
11/15/2015 9:25pm

This article is pretty interesting since there's so many useful info inside. Thank you.

Reply
11/16/2015 11:12pm

this site is very important

Reply

The post was an pretty informative.

Reply
11/27/2015 3:16pm

Good evening to all and have a nice sleep...

Reply
12/17/2015 7:30pm

The mineral normal water reminded everybody which includes remembrances, together using this type of loved one along with the spouse as well as my wife or husband and i moreover hold the merchandise in the past to learn necessary. a single unique.

Reply

I don't like the pictures, I love them. Wow

Reply
03/22/2016 4:05am

When we browse the web, we could have as numerous information promptly. Yet your own is the best one.

Reply
05/17/2016 3:58am

I discovered a great understanding on your blog site. I also suggest this blog with my friends

Reply

The Services are offered to the Users through specific online customization tools where the customers can design their desired product with our size templates

Reply

Hello, I also would like to share my opinion here, when i don’t know even about a straightforward thing related to Personal home pages, I always go to explore that from internet.

Reply

terima kasih atas infonya selama ini.

Reply

This content best and good for all website and app development.

Reply
09/29/2016 5:00am

Proper Lighting makes things attractive Like here each store seems pretty attractive and worth seeing .

Reply
10/04/2016 8:08am

This could be one particular of the most useful blogs

Reply
10/06/2016 5:46am

The site is really good and very informative related to the goods transport services. The way they share their information with us is very nice. I really like this. You are just great.

Reply
10/06/2016 9:06pm

Thanks for sharing here.
I am very happy to read your review.

Reply

Thanks.

Reply
10/14/2016 12:14am

You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!

Reply
10/17/2016 5:25am

Mind boggling focuses. Sound contentions. Keep up the considerable work.

Reply

Eumaxindia is a Advertising agencies based in chennai specializing in Newspaper ad,Outdoor ad,Television ad,Radio ad etc.

Reply
10/25/2016 4:09am

I am sharp of learning Flash, is there any bit of composing identified with Flash, assuming alright, then please post it, much appreciated.

Reply
10/25/2016 7:27am

This blog is very beneficial for everyone thanks admin has presented this blog

Reply
10/28/2016 12:47pm

well written post

Reply
10/29/2016 8:13am

I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.

Reply
11/02/2016 10:43am

Good article to read that nice and usefull content thanks for share

Reply

I have read this awesome blog thanks.

Reply
11/16/2016 11:52pm

http://arkanherbal.com/obat-penyakit-kanker-otak/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-kanker-serviks/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-salpingitis/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-prostatitis/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-aritmia-jantung/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-patah-tulang-kaki/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-cairan-di-paru-paru/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-mata-konjungtivitis/
http://arkanherbal.com/jenis-jenis-benjolan-di-payudara/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-kanker-payudara/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-mata-keruh/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-tumor-ovarium/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-turun-berok/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-kista-ginjal/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-infeksi-dinding-rahim/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-paru-paru-bocor/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-benjolan-di-dinding-rahim/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-radang-testis/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-kram-usus/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-penyakit-mata-glaukoma/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-hipertiroid/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-rahim-kering/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-eye-care-softgel-jakarta/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-slimming-capsule-jakarta/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-vig-power-capsule-jakarta/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-eye-care-softgel-bekasi/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-benjolan-di-testis/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-eye-care-softgel-tangerang/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-vig-power-capsule-tangerang/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-slimming-capsule-tangerang/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-vig-power-capsule-bandung/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-slimming-capsule-bandung/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-slimming-capsule-bandung/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-eye-care-softgel-surabaya/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-slimming-capsule-surabaya/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-vig-power-capsule-surabaya/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-eye-care-softgel-semarang/
http://arkanherbal.com/agen-vig-power-capsule-semarang/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-mata-juling/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-ablasio-retina/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-degenerasi-makula/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-buta-warna/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengeluarkan-dahak-di-tenggorokan/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-saraf-mata-yang-rusak/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-kanker-usus-12-jari/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-gondok-beracun/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-benjolan-di-miss-v/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-glaukoma/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-paru-paru-basah/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-hernia/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-retina-mata-lepas/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-saraf-mata-robek/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-mata-buram/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-buta-warna/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-gondok-beracun/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-flek-paru-paru/
http://arkanherbal.com/breast-care-capsule/
http://arkanherbal.com/lycopene-softgel/
http://arkanherbal.com/ganoderma-plus-capsule/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-amandel/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-kencing-batu/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-katarak/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-eksim-kering/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-kelenjar-tiroid/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-benjolan-di-leher/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-kencing-manis-kering/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-diabetes-basah/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-penyakit-flek-paru-paru/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-lemak-darah-tinggi/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-ablasio-retina/
http://arkanherbal.com/cordyceps-plus-capsule/
http://arkanherbal.com/blueberry-concentrate/
http://arkanherbal.com/deep-sea-fish-oil-softgel/
http://arkanherbal.com/triflex-capsule/
http://arkanherbal.com/lecithin-softgel/
http://arkanherbal.com/gastric-health-tablet/
http://arkanherbal.com/green-world-super-nutrition-nutrimax/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-retina-rusak/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-wasir/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-mata-plus/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-penyakit-gondok/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-penyakit-batu-empedu/
http://arkanherbal.com/cara-mengobati-mata-berkabut/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-infeksi-saluran-kemih/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-ambeien/
http://arkanherbal.com/obat-kanker-serviks/

Reply
11/29/2016 4:28am

It focuses on the important points, claims, and information. It discusses the positive aspects of the topic. The author does well, good points makes, and insightful observations.

Reply
11/30/2016 2:04am

Your article is superb and it most helpful. In my opinion such writing can be very much informative for many scholars.

Reply
12/02/2016 11:14pm

It does not hesitate to make decisions on very challenging matters and has confidence in decision making abilities. It always ensures that the appropriate people are included in the decision-making process.

Reply
12/03/2016 9:06am

3 month payday loans instant cash
personal loans monthly payments
3 month payday loans no credit check
12 month payday loans
loans with no credit check and monthly payments
monthly loans
12 month loans no credit check direct lenders

Reply
12/05/2016 4:37am

Paysaver Payday Loans supplies payday loan, cash loan loans as well as rapid cash solutions for whatever you need.

Reply
12/06/2016 3:29am

Your article is superb and it most helpful. In my opinion such writing can be very much informative for many scholars.

Reply
12/06/2016 4:25am

It is a Beautiful post with useful information. Thanks for sharing. It happily fulfils responsibilities commitment to excellence.

Reply
12/06/2016 10:11pm

I am glad to read this post, its an interesting one. I am always searching for quality posts and articles and this is what I found here, I hope you will be adding more in future. Thanks

Reply

For each and every country having different time in which you can file a claim for mishaps, we have to act quickly. Only a lawyer experienced mishap understand how much compensation you are qualified to get.

Reply
01/04/2017 7:17am

Thank you for the info.

Reply
01/08/2017 7:01pm

I can't say anything but thanks for this surprising article. It gives another thing to my mind.

Reply
01/25/2017 5:02am

trademark have nothing to do with day to day uses ? think twice if you think it not a issue. These companies terms and condition is big issue.

Reply
01/29/2017 11:13pm

Really a very fine way to express and looking a very pleasant article with full of healthy information. I am definitely going to tell in my class about this platform and the information shared here. Very well written.

Reply
02/02/2017 11:25am

So nice of you for sharing such useful information. I discovered a great understanding on your blog site. I also suggest this blog with my friends

Reply
02/14/2017 11:15pm

In this article you will learn the basics of setting up e-commerce stores as well as some solutions that make building online stores super easy and fast. Here are 10 most important tips for starting an online store.

Reply
02/19/2017 2:40pm

Thank finally I got what I need from your blog today. I've been searching for a long while. Thank you!

Reply
02/21/2017 3:24am

I am grateful for this blog to distribute knowledge about this significant topic. Here I found different segments and now I am going to use these new instructions with new enthusiasm.

Reply
02/21/2017 9:16pm

I read the blog and it was very nice.

Reply
02/22/2017 8:00am

Reply

Thanks for the valuable feedback. I think that strategy is sound and can be easily replicable. Great posts. I love this article.

Reply
03/13/2017 4:16am

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work read this driving blog

Reply
03/16/2017 1:39am

Great amazing things here. I am very satisfied to look your article. Thank you a lot

Reply
03/17/2017 9:22am

http://klgherbal.xyz/ciri-obat-hammer-of-thor-asli-dan-palsu/

Reply
03/17/2017 9:23am

http://hammerofthors.com/

Reply
03/17/2017 9:23am

http://klgherbal.xyz

Reply
03/18/2017 12:10am

Im thankful for the blog post.Much thanks again. Great.

Reply
03/27/2017 12:43am

Hello, Neat post. There's a problem with your website in web explorer,

Reply

The most effective way to treat the Sewage Water for utility is by enriched Bacteria digested in aerobic multi chambered and by treating with organic compound.

Reply
04/05/2017 5:45am

In this article we will describe the various types of self-defense products. Most of them are legal everywhere, some are not. You need to check for the legality of these products in your area before you get one. Read on to learn more.

Reply

Thanks for the valuable feedback. I think that strategy is sound and can be easily replicable. Great posts. I love this article.

Reply
04/18/2017 12:03am

Great, thanks for sharing this article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

Reply
04/19/2017 10:30pm

I like your pictures

Reply
04/24/2017 3:23am

Your article is superb and it most helpful.

Reply

Sometime it becomes very hard to find a well written and well established bog which give you correct and useful information. However, I found this blog and got some relevant information which are really helpful for me.

Reply
04/24/2017 9:24pm

Enthusiastic words written in this blog helped me to enhance my skills as well as helped me to know how I can help myself on my own. I am really glad to come at this platform.

Reply
04/24/2017 9:35pm

It is really a helpful blog to find some different source to add my knowledge. I came into aware of new professional blog and I am impressed with suggestions of author.

Reply
04/30/2017 9:19pm

Thanks for sharing here.
am from Indonesia too. Nice to meet you here.

Reply
04/30/2017 9:22pm

It is really a helpful blog to find some different source to add my knowledge.

Reply

Your article is superb and it most helpful.

Reply
04/30/2017 9:26pm

Hello, Neat post. There's a problem with your website in web explorer,

Reply
04/30/2017 9:28pm

LEVITRA 20mg ASLI

Reply
04/30/2017 9:29pm

OBAT HENDEL FOREX

Reply
04/30/2017 9:30pm

TITAN GEL PEMBESAR PENIS

Reply
04/30/2017 9:31pm

ALAT PEMBESAR PENIS

Reply

SEMENAX OBAT PENYUBUR SPERMA

Reply
04/30/2017 9:33pm

OBAT HAMMER OF THOR ASLI

Reply

CREAM KUDA JANTAN PEMBESAR PENIS

Reply

ALAT PEMBESAR PENIS BATHMATE HYDRO PUMP

Reply

VIMAX ASLI OBAT PEMBESAR PENIS

Reply
04/30/2017 9:40pm

AGEN OBAT KLG PILLS

Reply
04/30/2017 9:41pm

OBAT ANABOLIC RX24

Reply
04/30/2017 9:43pm

ALAT BANTU SEX

Reply
04/30/2017 9:44pm

PERANGSANG WANITA

Reply
04/30/2017 9:45pm

JUAL OBAT BIUS

Reply
04/30/2017 9:47pm

OBAT PERANGSANG WANITA

Reply
04/30/2017 9:49pm

Agen Jual Sextoys Jakarta

Reply
05/03/2017 9:01am

Nice Post !! I like it, it also comprises a lot of useful facts. thanks to share your experience.

Reply
05/05/2017 6:02am


Real-time and placement focused Software Testing training in chennai determined to provide end-to-end Software Testing Training Course in Chennai for Students and Professionals

Reply
05/10/2017 4:58am

https://www.mothersdayguide.org/category/mothers-day-wallpapers/

Reply
05/12/2017 4:24am

nice job i like it

Reply
05/19/2017 4:03am

OBAT KUAT VIAGRA 100mg ASLI

Reply
05/19/2017 4:04am

Hammer Of Thor

Reply
05/19/2017 4:06am

ghjtgfesgfdfgdrrgrghdfhbgnhgfhj

Reply
05/19/2017 4:06am

gret6h5wyu568j5656utrhgfhgfhdfh

Reply
05/20/2017 12:42am


Femora Cream If you have problems with cold sores, don't pick at them. This can delay the healing and can result in infection. The longer it takes for your sore to heal, the greater the likelihood it will leave a scar behind, particularly if it
s become infected.


Read More >>> http://www.wecareskincare.com/femora-cream/

Reply

Eumaxindia helps you find Advertising On Lamp Post in Chennai.Check out Advertising On Lamp Post business names, phone numbers to find the best Advertising On Lamp Post in Chennai.

Reply
06/04/2017 1:15am

I love this post.

Reply

Many thanks for getting enough time to discuss this, They have been a giant help for us. Thanks a whole lot.

Reply
06/27/2017 1:01am

Vimax Asli Canada Obat Pembesar Penis

Reply



Leave a Reply